On The Other Hand -
Book Reviews
Lifestyle, Cigars & More
Musings
About
On The Other Hand -
  • Book Reviews
  • Lifestyle, Cigars & More
  • Musings
  • About
Book Reviews

Considerations on the Causes of the Greatness of the Romans and their Decline by Montesquieu

March 4, 2024 by Barry J. Klazura No Comments

Charles Louis de Secondat, Baron de La Brede et de Montesquieu was from the middle of the 18th century through the founding of the United States, widely considered to be the preeminent political thinker of his time. His categorization of what constitutes a tyranny, an empire and a republic influenced our Founding Fathers in their debates and in the writing of the Federalist Papers. He was the principal architect of the theory of separation of powers and his main work, The Spirit of Law (1748) was well received throughout Europe and the thirteen colonies.

This work is considered a minor work, but I would like to suggest that no politician be allowed to take office until they have read and passed a test based on what he writes in this gem of a book.

Rome, like any organism or organization, had a period of growth followed by a decline. What were the causes of its growth? That is often asked as is, what caused its decline? Historians and others will argue those points for as long as Rome is remembered and everyone who attempts to answer those questions will be both correct and wrong. There were numerous causes but that in the end, as with other empires, the entire system simply imploded from lack of will, moral degeneracy and outside pressures that were simply more than could be managed given the resources available. Over time, the ideals and energy which helped the successful growth were lost and there were not enough good and strong men and women to hold the center together.

 Rome started as a small community, cut off from the sea, surrounded by numerous enemies, many of them larger. It had little natural wealth, barely any art and the citizens realized that the only way to enrich themselves was through pillage. Montesquieu believed that Rome’s power came from several factors, among them a constant drive for war, an unwillingness to accept defeat, an equal sharing of the plunder and a government which only allowed recognition and advancement through military success. Because Rome was always at war and because they adopted the best military practices of their individual neighbors, they simply excelled at war. They easily adopted the best skills of their military foes, such as cavalry, the Spanish short sword, etc. and use each in a way that helped to insure their victories. They developed a mindset which directed all activities of the State to be in the successful furtherance of war. Defeat was simply unacceptable and as was demonstrated during the war against Hannibal, no matter how often Roe’s field armies were defeated, they simply kept going after their nemesis until they achieved final victory. Such a mindset is not possible today as the technology of war simply makes war too expensive both in treasure and lives. So, what can we learn from the Romans? We can learn from them the reasons for their decline.

Continue reading
Share:
Reading time: 4 min

Barry J. Klazura

Barry Klazura sipping grappa

With a Masters Degree in Guerrilla Warfare and Totalitarianism, Mr. Klazura was well prepped for a career in Sales and General Management, consulting on corporate startups and turnarounds as well as lecturing on history and politics.  For the past twenty years he has focused on being a financial advisor and consulting.

Delivered To Your Inbox

Sign up to get an email when a new article is published.

Topics

  • American Civil War
  • Biography
  • Book Reviews
  • Cigar Reviews
  • Coronavirus
  • Current Affairs
  • Education
  • Environment
  • Factoids
  • Government
  • Lifestyle, Cigars & More
  • Liquid Refreshments
  • Musings
  • Quips and Historical Facts
  • Society
  • Travel
  • Uncategorized
  • World War I

Subjects

book Books-Russia/Soviet Union Books 21st Century Books 1919-2000 Books Ancient to 1900 Books Asia Books Biography Books Fiction Books Germany 1919-1945 Books Pre-WWI books Viet Nam books world war I Books WW1 Books WWI Books WWII Cigar Friendly Location Amsterdam Cigar Friendly Locations-London Cigar Friendly Locations-New Orleans Cigar Friendly Locations-New York Civil War Coronavirus Environment Korean War World War I World War One

Recent Articles

At Stalin’s Side by Valentin Berezhkov

July 15, 2026
The Price of Victory by N.A.M. Rodger

The Price of Victory by N.A.M. Rodger

June 26, 2026
Frontsoldaten: The German Soldier in World War II by Stephen G. Fritz

Frontsoldaten: The German Soldier in World War II by Stephen G. Fritz

June 5, 2026
Organizer of Victory, 1943-1945, George C. Marshall by Forrest C. Pogue

Organizer of Victory, 1943-1945, George C. Marshall by Forrest C. Pogue

May 26, 2026
Illegals Released & Our Leaders

Illegals Released & Our Leaders

May 10, 2026

Inquiries and Comments

For general inquiries and comments, email AOTOHcomments@gmail.com.

Facebook
© 2020 And On The Other Hand. All rights reserved.