On The Other Hand -
Book Reviews
Lifestyle, Cigars & More
Musings
About
On The Other Hand -
  • Book Reviews
  • Lifestyle, Cigars & More
  • Musings
  • About
Book Reviews

Against all Odds: A True Story of Ultimate Courage and Survival in World War II by Alex Kershaw

July 13, 2025 by Barry J. Klazura No Comments

At the end of the Second World War, German Field-Marshal Albert Kesselring whose troops fought both British and American troops in Italy and Western Europe, was asked “What was the best American division faced by troops under your command on either the Italian or Western Fronts?”. Without hesitation he said, “The Marne men.”

Who were the “Marne men?”  They were the men of the U.S. Army’s 3rd Division. They won more medals than any other infantry division in Europe and within its ranks were at least one of every U.S. medal, including the Medal of Honor; some medals were won by those two men as many as three times. Their names were Audie Murphy Maurice Britt. Both men received major wounds, and Murphy would have the more public but also more troubled private lives. Here is a list of medals won by Murphy: * Medal of Honor *2- Silver Stars * 3-Bronze Stars * Distinguished Service Cross *3-Purple Hearts. In total, the “Marne” division won more than one-fourth of all Medals of Honor won by the ground forces, an amazing accomplishment. The winning of medals helped determine when the serviceman was able to go home and at the end of the war, who could be discharged and in what order.

The book follows a number of individuals from the divisions landing in French North Africa, through the battles in Sicily and Italy, including Anzio plus the landing in the south of France through the final battles in the Colmar pocket. While Army psychologists thought that the “breaking point” of an infantryman was two-hundred days of continual combat, many of the men of the division were in continuous battles for over four-hundred days, and the survival rates was about seven percent.

Kershaw continues his excellent writing in that while he describes the overall strategic scope of the battles, focuses on the lives of the men at the most basic level. He has obviously taken great care in doing his research, in his interviews and writing to bring the men, both high and low to life. Their stories and exploits put modern day movies and stories to shame, for these were real individuals taking huge risks in order to lead their men and insure that as many of them would return home at wars end. It is a shame that young boys of today watch silly comic book heroes in movies instead of learning about real bravery as exhibited by men of their great grandfathers and grandfathers’ generations. It is hard to say anything positive about war, but to see the bravery and selflessness of the men in this book makes one realize the amazing ability of ordinary men to do extraordinary deeds.

Share:
Reading time: 2 min

Barry J. Klazura

Barry Klazura sipping grappa

With a Masters Degree in Guerrilla Warfare and Totalitarianism, Mr. Klazura was well prepped for a career in Sales and General Management, consulting on corporate startups and turnarounds as well as lecturing on history and politics.  For the past twenty years he has focused on being a financial advisor and consulting.

Delivered To Your Inbox

Sign up to get an email when a new article is published.

Topics

  • American Civil War
  • Biography
  • Book Reviews
  • Cigar Reviews
  • Coronavirus
  • Current Affairs
  • Education
  • Environment
  • Factoids
  • Government
  • Lifestyle, Cigars & More
  • Liquid Refreshments
  • Musings
  • Quips and Historical Facts
  • Society
  • Travel
  • Uncategorized
  • World War I

Subjects

book Books-Russia/Soviet Union Books 21st Century Books 1919-2000 Books Ancient to 1900 Books Asia Books Biography Books Fiction Books Germany 1919-1945 Books Pre-WWI books Viet Nam books world war I Books WW1 Books WWI Books WWII Cigar Friendly Location Amsterdam Cigar Friendly Locations-London Cigar Friendly Locations-New Orleans Cigar Friendly Locations-New York Civil War Coronavirus Environment Korean War World War I World War One

Recent Articles

At Stalin’s Side by Valentin Berezhkov

July 15, 2026
The Price of Victory by N.A.M. Rodger

The Price of Victory by N.A.M. Rodger

June 26, 2026
Frontsoldaten: The German Soldier in World War II by Stephen G. Fritz

Frontsoldaten: The German Soldier in World War II by Stephen G. Fritz

June 5, 2026
Organizer of Victory, 1943-1945, George C. Marshall by Forrest C. Pogue

Organizer of Victory, 1943-1945, George C. Marshall by Forrest C. Pogue

May 26, 2026
Illegals Released & Our Leaders

Illegals Released & Our Leaders

May 10, 2026

Inquiries and Comments

For general inquiries and comments, email AOTOHcomments@gmail.com.

Facebook
© 2020 And On The Other Hand. All rights reserved.